Why not try and encourage people to do better than to just drive them out, it's all very well being an "expert" but I would have thought that a forum is not just about knowing everything, it's about helping others out, sharing your finds, knowledge, and giving tips to others. frankly it's easy to criticise, but unless you back your criticism up with plausible explanations, then it's pointless.
If we all knew everything, then what's the point of a forum??????
To be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if Oldbouy has now p***ed off, which is a shame, because regardless of the "quality" of the report, the guy was/is enthusiastic, which in my view is a great shame if he is now not. It's not like he was some chav scum out to destroy.
Honestly, what next.