Sorry Magmo we've completely derailed your thread. =/
No problem... Debate is good though a lot of peoples only experience of 3d has been full length films where still pictures playd back in high res through a HDMI 1.4 conection is very good.
One thing I do agree on and it is the same case for HDR and that is that it can be over done. Some subjects are great in it, the wrong subject can be crap. I think a subject such as Pystock would be ideal.
I see you said you had seen 5 3D films, that is 5 more than I have
Anotrher thing that some people seen to think is that 3D photography is a new fad, it has been around for over 100 years in one form or another, I have been into 3D photography since I was 11.
My camera has a Lenticular lens on the lcd panel, like the Nintedo 3d but higher res and you don't need glasses, whe the screens get larger and cheaper that willbe the next step, but not the final step.
It is good that everyone has given an opinion and it would be a boring world if everyone had the same opinion.
Happy New year.
mo